Most people compare water heaters by price and warranty. Those matter, but the choices that decide whether the heater runs well for fifteen years are quieter: the size, the fuel, where it goes and how it is installed.
When buying a water heater, decide the fuel (gas or electric), the type (tank or tankless), the size for your household, and where it will sit, including venting, a drain pan, a relief valve and discharge pipe, an expansion tank where needed, and access for service. Installation quality matters as much as the unit, so ask what is included before comparing prices.
- Size by how much hot water you use at the busiest hour, not by house size.
- Gas needs venting and a correctly sized gas line. Electric needs the right circuit.
- A drain pan and relief pipe are not optional above living space.
- The cheapest quote often leaves out the parts that make it safe.
- Plan for service: a flush valve, isolation valves and room to work.
Fuel and type
- Gas tank: quick recovery and lower running cost where gas is available, with venting and a gas connection.
- Electric tank: simpler venting and installation, slower recovery, a dedicated circuit.
- Tankless: continuous hot water and a smaller footprint, with a higher installed cost, venting and a larger gas line. See our guide to tank or tankless.
Size
Tank sizes are judged by the first-hour rating, which is how much hot water the unit can deliver in an hour starting full. Count the number of people, bathrooms and heavy users. A household with several showers in the morning needs more than the same house on a quiet schedule. A plumber can help you choose.
Where it goes
- Attics: need a drain pan, a drain line and good access. A leak ruins a ceiling.
- Garages: keep flammable products away, and check that the unit is protected from vehicle damage.
- Closets: need clearance, ventilation for gas units and a floor drain or a pan.
What should come with the installation
- A new relief valve and a correctly routed discharge pipe
- A drain pan and a drain line where a leak could do damage
- New connectors and shutoff valves, including a gas shutoff on gas units
- An expansion tank where the system calls for one
- Proper venting and clearances
- A permit where required, and a test before the plumber leaves
Houston considerations
Hard water speeds up scale, so a softener or an annual flush helps. Attic installations are common, so drain pans matter. After flooding, appliances that were wet should be checked before use.
Questions to ask
- What is included in the price?
- What size do you recommend, and why?
- What will you do about the old unit?
- Is a permit required, and who arranges it?
- Will I get a written work order and invoice?
See our water heater experts page and water heater installation.
Frequently asked questions
How long does a water heater last?
Many tank heaters last about a decade, give or take, depending on water quality and maintenance.
Is bigger always better?
No. An oversized tank costs more to run, and an undersized one runs out.
Do I need an expansion tank?
In many homes with a closed system, yes. A plumber can check.
Is a permit needed to replace a water heater?
Often. The rules depend on your city or county.
Gas or electric?
It depends on what you have, the cost of each and your household's use.
