Water heater problems tend to arrive with the same few questions. These are the ones we hear most, answered briefly.
Most water heater repairs are replaceable parts: a heating element or thermostat on an electric unit, a thermocouple, pilot assembly or gas valve on a gas unit, or a relief valve on either. A leaking tank cannot be repaired and needs replacing. A plumber diagnoses the fault, gives you the price for the repair and, if it makes sense, for a replacement, and tests the heater afterwards.
- No hot water: check the breaker or pilot first.
- Rumbling usually means scale. Flushing helps.
- Water from the tank is a replacement. Water from a fitting may be a repair.
- A heater near the end of its life may not be worth a major repair.
- Gas smells are an emergency. Leave and call 911 or the gas utility first.
Why do I have no hot water?
Electric: a tripped breaker, a failed element or a faulty thermostat. Gas: the pilot out, a failed thermocouple or flame sensor, or a faulty gas valve. Check the breaker or the pilot light, and if it does not solve it, call.
Why is the water only lukewarm?
An electric heater may have one failed element out of two. A gas heater may have a dirty burner. Sediment in the tank can also reduce capacity. The thermostat may be set too low.
What is that rumbling noise?
Scale and sediment at the bottom of the tank, with water trapped beneath it. A flush often reduces it, and a softener prevents it. See our page on water softener installation.
Why is my heater leaking?
If the water comes from a pipe connection, a valve or the relief valve, it can often be repaired. If it comes from the tank, the tank has corroded and needs replacing. Turn off the water and power or gas, and call.
My pilot light keeps going out
A worn thermocouple, a draft, a dirty pilot assembly or a gas pressure problem. A plumber can find which.
How long does a repair take?
Often a single visit if the part is on the truck. Some parts need ordering.
Repair or replace?
It depends on the age, the fault and the cost. See our water heater experts page for the options, and our water heater repair service.
Frequently asked questions
How long does a water heater last?
Many tank heaters last around a decade, depending on water and care.
Can I relight a pilot light myself?
Often, following the manufacturer's instructions. If it will not stay lit, call.
Is it safe to leave it running if it leaks?
No. Turn off the supply, the power or the gas, and call.
Why is the water too hot?
The thermostat setting or a faulty thermostat. It is a scald risk, so turn it down and call.
Does flushing help?
Yes, it removes sediment and can reduce noise.
